Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards
ThinkAdvisor
John Manganaro

Retirement Planning > Spending in Retirement > Income Planning

Can You Beat My Score on This Retirement Literacy Test?

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.
This is the latest in a series of columns about Social Security and retirement income planning.

As a reporter whose work has focused almost exclusively on the topic of retirement planning for more than a decade now, I pride myself on having built up a solid foundation of knowledge about the big financial and behavioral complexities that define life after work.

If my experience has taught me anything, however, it is that there is always something more to learn about retirement, and I was reminded of that fact yet again this week when I put my knowledge to the test through a retirement income literacy quiz developed by a team of researchers at the American College of Financial Services.

Though I did manage to outperform the average respondent’s score by a healthy margin, I nonetheless found myself getting tripped up in a few areas pertaining to some nuanced topics, particularly cash value life insurance and the intricacies of Medicaid. The experience got me thinking: How would our readers do on the 38-question quiz, which asks about everything from annuity payout rates to mutual fund fees?

For context, just one in five Americans earned a passing grade on the quiz when the researchers ran a recent experiment that saw thousands of randomized respondents give it a go. Even more discouraging, according to report authors Chet Bennetts, Michael Finke, Eric Ludwig, Steve Parrish and Kaylee Ranck, was the average score of just 31%.

Some positive signs are to be found in the data, according to the researchers, such as the fact that Americans who are older and nearer retirement seem to have at least slightly better knowledge about key financial concepts related to retirement. There’s also good indication that people have a decent sense of their own knowledge levels, and that higher levels of educational and wealth attainment lead to higher levels of “retirement literacy.”

The researchers theorize that those who are wealthier and further along in their careers more commonly work with advisors, and they simply have more lived financial experience to rely upon when answering tricky quiz questions. But overall, the findings suggest that the financial industry’s education efforts seem to have fallen flat when it comes to the topic of spending in retirement.

As such, the researchers said their quiz can be a powerful tool in the hands of any advisor who serves clients facing the “decumulation challenge.”

Beyond testing their own knowledge on a range of important topics, advisors can use the results to pinpoint their clients’ income planning blind spots and create tailored educational resources. They can also foster some healthy office competition by challenging their colleagues and comparing results.

There’s Nothing Simple About Retirement

A review of the range of the quiz questions reveals just how complex the retirement planning topic is.

The quiz starts with a question about safe withdrawal rates for a 50-50 portfolio of bonds and stocks that must last for 30 years with normal assumed future returns before moving on to address such topics as sequence of returns risk, inflation hedging and the age at which required minimum distributions from tax-qualified retirement accounts must begin.

The first question that tripped me up asked, “Which one of the following is true about cash value life insurance?” As I now know, it is true that the cash value portion of the policy will accumulate tax deferred, but it’s not true that you typically cannot borrow from the cash value or that the policy will expire after a specified period of time.

I also overestimated the ideal stock allocation for the typical retirement portfolio, and another question that gave me pause spoke to what types of services traditional Medicare will cover between routine dental care, physical exams, hearing aids and several other options. Without revealing the answer, I can say I didn’t realize just how many types of services are cut out of Medicare policies and therefore must be paid for through other policies or out-of-pocket spending.

In addition to the intricacies of Medicare and Medicaid, my other weakest knowledge area is long-term care planning and nursing home expenses. For example, I had to guess on the true or false question asking about whether Medicare typically pays for the costs of a nursing home for the first year, and I guessed wrong.

Finally, I missed the mark on a question asking who pays for the majority of long-term care expenses provided in nursing homes. Suffice to say, it’s not Medicare nor private insurance.

Retirement Knowledge Powers Confidence

So, how did I do overall on the test? I’m proud (and admittedly a bit relieved) to report that I got a solid B-plus, scoring a 34 out of 38 possible correct answers. Far from a perfect score, but I have clearly benefited from more than a decade of reporting on the topic of retirement planning.

More important than bragging rights, however, is the fact that I had hoped and expected to do about that well, and that fact reflects one of the big survey results that caught the research team’s attention. That is, the researchers ended up being surprised by just how well respondents’ self-ratings of their retirement income knowledge matched up with their actual scores on the literacy test.

Among those who didn’t rate themselves very highly in terms of retirement knowledge, a whopping 73% had less than $100,000 saved for retirement. Compare that to the group at the other end of the spectrum — those who felt confident about their retirement smarts. Some 81% of this group had savings above $100,000. Put simply, as retirement planning knowledge improves, so does confidence.

My results also reflect that, although both the overall scores and underlying scores on the 12 retirement knowledge areas are low across the board, respondents show greater knowledge in areas having to do with recently lived experience. For example, people scored higher on questions about inflation and housing costs, while older Americans scored better on questions about Medicare.

Finally, the authors said their work establishes a compelling link between retirement literacy and working directly with a financial advisor — something I have the benefit of doing on a professional basis every day. Advised respondents have higher scores across all knowledge areas, are more financially well, and feel more confident about retirement.

On average, advised respondents scored 11 points higher on retirement income literacy than those without an advisor (38% vs. 27%), while those who work with financial advisors score nine points higher than those who don’t (50% vs. 41%) on financial well-being, measured using the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Financial Well-Being Scale. Further, having a financial advisor predicts increased confidence and decreased stress and anxiety, controlling for demographic factors.


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.