(Bloomberg) — The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to review a Puerto Rico local debt-restructuring law rejected by a lower court risks prolonging negotiations with creditors to reduce the island’s obligations just as the commonwealth says its running out of cash.
The high court Friday said it would hear an appeal by the commonwealth to reinstate an island law that would allow some public agencies to ask bondholders to accept losses on the securities they hold. The disputed law would affect about $22 billion of the $70 billion in debt that Puerto Rico is seeking to impose losses on for holders.
Much of the debt is related to retirement benefits obligations.
Restoring the law would give the commonwealth additional leverage as it negotiates with mutual funds, hedge funds, bond-insurance companies and lenders, said Matt Fabian, a partner at Concord, Mass.-based Municipal Market Analytics. Puerto Rico may also decide to put on hold an agreement between the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority and some bondholders to reduce the utility’s $8.2 billion in obligations through a debt exchange, he said. Insurers who guarantee a portion of the debt still need to sign off on the accord and the island’s legislature must ratify the agreement.
“It gives them an additional stick with which to threatened creditors,” Fabian said. “And that restructuring agreement is tenuous enough that this is one more burden that just might break it up,” he said about the Prepa bondholder accord.
Puerto Rico and its agencies borrowed for years to paper over budget deficits as the island’s economy struggled to grow. Lawmakers in June 2014 passed the debt-restructuring law to help some corporations negotiate with creditors and cut their debts. Gov. Alejandro Garcia Padilla a year later said investors need to take losses to help the island’s economy expand again.
“The lack of a final resolution to the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority negotiations, which have been delayed by the unyielding attitude of certain creditors, demonstrates the importance of a mechanism to compel stakeholders to engage in good faith negotiations,” Melba Acosta, president of the Government Development Bank, which oversees the island’s debt restructurings, said in a statement Friday.
The court may hear arguments as soon as late March and rule by June. Prepa faces deadlines before then: a $196 million interest payment is due Jan. 1.
The commonwealth says the debt-restructuring legislation fills a gap in federal bankruptcy law, which prohibits filing by Puerto Rico and its agencies and municipalities. BlueMountain Capital Management, Franklin Advisers Inc. and OppenheimerFunds, which hold more than $2 billion in Prepa bonds, are fighting against the local law and claim a high court review is unnecessary because they’ve already agreed to a restructuring plan with the power utility.
OppenheimerFunds is a unit of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company.