In the world of nonqualified deferred compensation, there’s a new sheriff in town named 409A. It took a while for this law to make itself clear, but at the end of this coming year, it unquestionably is the law of the land. If employers want to avoid running afoul of the law, the coming weeks are key to reviewing and implementing proper procedures for their deferred compensation plans.
Internal Revenue Code (IRC) 409A became law in 2004, but because of the need for regulations and further clarifications, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) provided employers with several compliance extensions. Most of the extensions were set to expire this year. On September 10, 2007, the IRS issued Notice 2007-78, which provided some limited relief.
The basic rules established by this notice were two-fold: (1) the deadline for achieving documentary compliance was extended from December 31, 2007 to December 31, 2008; and (2) eligibility for this extended deadline was limited to those plans that designate in writing prior to January 1, 2008 a compliant time and form of payment for benefits subject to 409A.
Surrendering to significant pressure from the legal community for more time to comply, the IRS issued Notice 2007-86 on October 22, 2007. This notice generally extends the transitional period for compliance with the final regulations to December 31, 2008. The notice also confirms that the U.S. Treasury Department and the IRS expect to issue guidance regarding a correction program as soon as possible.
A day later, the IRS released Notice 2007-89, which provides interim guidance on reporting and wage withholding requirements for calendar year 2007 with respect to deferrals of compensation and amounts includible in gross income under ?409A. For all intents and purposes, employers have until the end of 2008 to bring their nonqualified deferred compensation plans into compliance, and they are exempt from having to report in 2007 the amount of deferrals (that are not subject to tax under section 409A) that occur in 2007. This does not exempt employers from reporting 409A violations; and they obviously still need to report actual deferred compensation payouts.
These notices should not be interpreted as a blanket extension. Consider, for example, the value of deciding what distribution options will be available in the 409A compliant plan this year. If the election is made before the end of 2007, it can affect distribution events that occur in 2008. If companies wait until 2008, the election will only affect events that occur in 2009 and after. Financial advisors can play a key role in assuring that employers know what must (or ought to) be done now and what can wait.
IRC 409A was passed as part of the American Jobs Creation Act in 2004. The more than four-year delay between the passage of the law and the effective date for compliance is a testament to the complexity of the law and the need for knowledgeable support and advice. Employers need to review their plans, bring them into compliance where needed, and move on.
It is important to get the process started now. Even though the IRS extended compliance yet another year, one may assume that their charity will not be extended any further. Chart 1 shows some of the key items the employer needs to address this coming year. In essence, this is the year in which employers can clean up the operation of their nonqualified deferred compensation plans and employees can change their distribution options. Chart 2 shows some of the key items that can wait pending further clarification from the IRS.
Consider this example: Success Corp. has had a voluntary nonqualified deferred compensation plan since 2000. The company has been following the rules under IRC 409A in good faith in the past two years, but it has not brought its actual nonqualified deferred compensation plan document into compliance.