Editor’s Note: See Q
for a discussion of how the CARES Act changed the plan loan rules for 2020.
Qualified plans may permit participants to borrow from their accounts, but are not required to permit loans. A loan from a plan to a participant or to a beneficiary will be treated as a taxable distribution unless it meets certain requirements regarding:
(1) the enforceability of the agreement,
(2) the term of the loan,
(3) repayment, and
(4) a limitation on the maximum loan that may be made ( Q 3954).1
In certain situations, a violation of one of these requirements will not result in taxation to the participant if the violation is corrected under EPCRS. The IRS expanded the EPCRS program with respect to plan loans in Revenue Procedure 2019-19. Plans may now use the self-correction program to correct errors with respect to defaulted loans, failure to obtain spousal consent if necessary and situations where the plan issues more loans than are permitted under the plan. With respect to defaulted loans, the participant will generally be responsible for making a corrective payment, although the employer will be required to pay interest in certain circumstances. For corrections for failure to obtain spousal consent, the spouse must be notified so that he or she can provide consent. The revenue procedure also permits plans to be amended retroactively to allow for the number of plans loans that were actually permitted.
2 Repayment of a loan treated as a distribution will be considered a nondeductible employee contribution for tax purposes.
3 When a recipient’s benefit is later distributed to the recipient, the amount already taxed will not be taxed again. Repayments constitute investment in the contract (i.e., basis)
4 and are not considered annual additions subject to the IRC Section 415 limits.
5 Plan Qualification
A qualified plan generally can provide for loans to participants if they are adequately secured, bear a reasonable rate of interest, have a reasonable repayment schedule, and are made available on a nondiscriminatory basis.
6 If a plan is subject to automatic survivor benefit requirements, the loan may require spousal consent ( Q
3882).
Treatment of a loan as a distribution for tax purposes generally does not affect the plan’s tax qualification. A bona fide loan that is not a prohibited transaction ( Q
3980) will not cause a pension plan to fail to satisfy the requirement that a pension plan primarily provide benefits for employees or their beneficiaries over a period of years or for life after retirement.
7 When a plan loaned out almost all of its assets to the company president, without seeking adequate security, a fair return, or prompt repayment, the plan was held not to have been operated for the exclusive benefit of the employees and plan disqualification was justified.
8 A deemed distribution under IRC Section 72(p) will not be treated as an actual distribution for purposes of the qualification requirements of IRC Section 401; thus, plan qualification will not be affected by reason of a deemed distribution. If a participant’s accrued benefit is reduced or offset to repay a plan loan, an actual distribution occurs for purposes of IRC Section 401. This occurs generally when a participant with a loan terminates employment with the employer, if so specified in the loan agreement. An offset distribution from a 401(k) plan or a pension plan at a time when the plan is not otherwise permitted to make a distribution would result in plan disqualification.
9
Planning Point: Under prior law, if a loan from a qualified plan had not been repaid when the participant left employment or the plan was terminated (among other reasons), the outstanding loan balance would be offset against his or her account balance and would become taxable if not rolled over to another retirement account within 60 days. Under the 2017 tax reform legislation, the 60-day deadline is extended to the participant’s tax filing deadline for the tax year in which the offset occurs if the amount is treated as distributed from the participant’s qualified plan because either: (1) the plan was terminated, or (2) the participant failed to meet the loan repayment terms because of a separation from employment (if the plan provides that the accrued unpaid loan amount must be offset at this time).
A plan loan that is secured by a participant’s or a beneficiary’s interest in the plan but that is not a prohibited transaction generally will not be an assignment or alienation of plan benefits that would disqualify a plan.
10 If there is a tacit understanding that collection of a loan is not intended, however, the loan may be treated as a disqualifying distribution if made at a time when the plan is not permitted to make distributions.
11 When an actual distribution follows a deemed distribution, a plan must treat the loan transition amount as an outstanding loan that is taxable on actual distribution. The loan transition amount is the amount by which the initial default amount, attributed as tax basis, exceeds the tax basis immediately preceding the transition date, plus any increase in tax basis thereafter. The plan may not attribute investment in the contract as a loan repayment ( Q
3973). The tax basis in the distribution is determined based on the initial default amount and, to the extent that a tax basis has been attributed, it must be reduced by the initial default amount.
Cash repayments made after a loan is deemed to have been distributed will increase the participant’s tax basis as if they were after-tax contributions, although they are not treated as after-tax contributions for other purposes.
12 Prohibited transactions. Plan loans that do not meet any of the requirements for a prohibited transaction exemption ( Q
3980) could result in excise taxes and possible plan disqualification. The prohibited transaction rules apply to a loan that does not meet the exemption requirements, even if it is treated as (and taxed as) a distribution ( Q
3980). Loans from a qualified plan to certain S corporation shareholders, partners, and sole proprietors also may qualify for the prohibited transaction exemption ( Q
3980).
13 Investments in residential mortgages. Plan investments in residential mortgages of employees, other than officers, directors, or owners, or their beneficiaries, are permitted but are subject to limitations of IRC Section 72(p) unless they are made in the ordinary course of a plan investment program that is not limited to participants and their beneficiaries.
14 A longer term than the five years allowed for other plan loans may be permitted ( Q
3954).
Mandatory Withholding
Distributions that constitute eligible rollover distributions from a qualified plan generally are subject to mandatory income tax withholding at the rate of 20 percent, unless the participant elects a direct rollover.
15 The IRS has stated that a deemed distribution attributable to a plan loan that does not meet the requirements of IRC Section 72(p) will not be subject to the 20 percent mandatory withholding requirement because such a distribution cannot be an eligible rollover distribution.
Where a participant’s accrued benefit is reduced or offset to repay a plan loan, such as when employment is terminated, the offset amount may constitute an eligible rollover distribution.
16 Mandatory withholding is required on a deemed distribution of a loan, or a loan repayment by benefit offset, to the extent that a transfer included cash or property other than employer securities at the same time.
17
1. IRC § 72(p)(2); Treas. Reg. § 1.72(p)-1, A-3.
2. Rev. Proc. 2019-19.
3. Sen. Rept. 97-494, 97th Cong. 2nd Sess.
4. Let. Rul. 9122059.
5. Notice 82-22, 1982-2 CB 751.
6. IRC § 4975(d)(1); Notice 82-22, 1982-2 CB 751; Rev. Rul. 71-437, 1971-2 CB 185; Rev. Rul. 67-288, 1967-2 CB 151.
7. Notice 82-22, 1982-2 CB 751.
8.
Winger’s Dept. Store, Inc. v. Comm., 82 TC 869 (1984).
9. Treas. Reg. § 1.72(p)-1, A-12, A-13.
10. Treas. Reg. § 1.401(a)-13(d)(2).
See Q
3912.
See also Notice 82-22, 1982-2 CB 751.
11. Rev. Rul. 71-437, 1971-2 CB 185.
12. Treas. Reg. § 1.72(p)-1, A-19 through A-21.
See Treas. Reg. § 1.72(p)-1, A-1 through A-18.
13. IRC § 4975(f)(6)(B)(iii).
14. Treas. Reg. § 1.72(p)-1, A-18.
15. IRC § 3405(c).
16. Notice 93-3, 1993-1 CB 293.
17. Treas. Reg. § 1.72(p)-1, A-15.