Close Close

Regulation and Compliance > Federal Regulation > FINRA

Why Some Consumers Are More Vulnerable to Financial Scams

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

What You Need to Know

  • Scammers often promised easy money or lucrative investments, or posed as IRS agents demanding payment of back taxes, a study found.
  • Two overseas call center workers using the back taxes scam defrauded their targets out of $57,000 in 10 days.
  • Engaging with scammers and losing money was associated with social isolation and low levels of financial literacy.

With World Investor Week just around the corner, Oct. 4 to Oct. 10, a two-year study released this week asks why some people are more likely to lose money to fraud.

The research found that attitudes and beliefs that shape the ways in which study participants looked at the world — called “mental frames” — may have influenced how they reacted to scams, according to investigators from the FINRA Investor Education Foundation, the Better Business Bureau Institute for Marketplace Trust and the University of Minnesota. 

They propose that mental frames that govern compliance, opportunity, intelligence and order may have affected the way that interviewees interpreted what scammers told them. 

People were more likely to lose money if they believed that authority should not be challenged, financial opportunities are a zero-sum game with clear winners and losers, the world is organized to benefit good people and asking too many questions can make a person seem ignorant.

“This research gives us new ways to understand who is at risk for losing money to financial scams and opens novel possibilities for protecting people against different forms of fraud,” Gerri Walsh, FINRA Foundation president, said in a statement. 

“We hope these insights into the role that beliefs and attitudes play in fraud victimization will stimulate additional research and the development of effective strategies to reduce consumer losses.”

Investigators identified study participants from a pool of people who had filed reports with BBB Scam Tracker, an online fraud reporting tool. Researchers from Metro Tribal, an ethnographic-based social insight firm, conducted in-depth interviews that yielded key insights.

Scammers and the Scammed

The researchers spoke with 17 people who were targeted by scammers. In recorded interviews, some participants said scammers had promised them easy money or lucrative investments. Others said they had gotten phone calls from fraudsters posing as IRS agents and demanding payment of back taxes.

Researchers also interviewed two young men who worked from an overseas call center to defraud hundreds of people using the IRS scam. As described in the report, the men said their boss used a “voicemail blaster” to send out 50,000 recorded messages every day, threatening legal action if the calls were not immediately returned.

According to the two men, more than three-quarters of return callers simply cursed them, but about a quarter took the message seriously and sounded “panicked.” By their 10th day on the job, they said they had already conned targets out of $57,000.

A related quantitative study based on a sample of 1,408 Americans and Canadians who were targeted and reported a scam was released in September 2019. 

Forty-seven percent of participants said they did not engage with the fraudster and so were not victimized, 30% engaged but did not lose money and 23% engaged and ultimately lost money. Scams involving online purchases correlated with the highest levels of engagement and victimization. 

The study found that survey respondents who engaged and became victims were more likely to report being exposed to those scams on a website or through social media than via telephone, mail or email. Engaging and losing money was also associated with social isolation and low levels of financial literacy. 

This research further found that prior knowledge of scams and fraud can reduce susceptibility.