Close Close

Portfolio > ETFs > Broad Market

Does Black Friday Still Matter?

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

Over the past two years, Black Friday sales estimates have fallen: Does that mean the unofficial kick-off to retailers’ holiday season has lost its impact?

The last few years have seen some pushback from consumers as retailers have extended their Black Friday shopping events to start on Thursday, leading some big brands like Nordstrom and Costco to pledge to leave their stores closed on Thanksgiving, and outdoor supplier REI to extend that pledge to Friday.

What does that mean for investors?

Online retail sales have grown faster than Black Friday sales, according to a recent paper from LPL. The report noted that Cyber Monday grew out of consumers’ tendency to take advantage of their employers’ faster network speeds to do some holiday shopping online when they returned to work after Thanksgiving. Now that broadband Internet is widely available, online retailers aren’t as dependent on that Monday shopping boost, but many still offer deals on that day, LPL wrote.

The growth in online sales doesn’t exclude traditional retailers. Many also offer online shopping, with larger stores often leveraging their distribution network and multiple locations to allow free shipping to a customer’s local store, according to the report.

However, strong cyber sales haven’t offset an overall decline in sales over the four-day period, LPL found.

While online sales grew from $1.5 billion in 2012, to $1.7 billion the next year and $2 billion in 2014, those numbers are dwarfed by the declining Black Friday sales numbers: $59.1 billion in 2012, followed by $57.4 billion and $50.9 billion over the next two years.

“The recent trend of stores opening on Thanksgiving, as well as additional discounting closer to Christmas (Super Saturday, the Saturday before Christmas, is one such example), indicates customers may be spreading out purchases throughout the holiday season and diminishing the importance of the four-day shopping period. Sales for the holiday season overall have actually increased over the years, despite the drop in Black Friday sales,” LPL wrote.

In fact, many retailers’ fiscal year ends in January to include holiday sales, meaning the first quarter shows the impact of holiday shopping. LPL found that Q1 sales have increased steadily over the past 15 years, and gross profit margins are highest during this period of highly discounted products for retailers.

There are a few reasons for the increase in gross profit margins despite discounted prices, LPL found. First, suppliers may be absorbing some of the impact, as many retailers negotiate lower prices. They also tend to offer discounts on big-ticket items like electronics.

“Given high sales and solid overall margins, retailers are likely to continue offering Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals for the foreseeable future,” according to the report.

Comparing Retail Sales to the Stock Market

LPL used its own research and data from FactSet, Standard and Poor’s, the National Retail Federation and comScore to compare sales estimates and first-quarter sales from Black Friday and Cyber Monday, with fourth and first quarter moves in the S&P Retail Select Industry Index.

It found that while sales estimates for Black Friday and Cyber Monday are highly correlated with the 15 largest retailers in the S&P’s retail index, meaning the estimates are “generally in line with reality,” there is “little, if any, relationship between Black Friday/Cyber Monday sales estimates (or actual reported sales results) and the performance of the S&P Retail Select Industry Index in the fourth quarter (or the S&P 500 as a whole) since 2008.”

Overall, LPL concluded, while Black Friday and Cyber Monday are good predictors of holiday sales, they don’t say much about the stock market.

That’s because market participants mostly focus on their own forecasts. Over the past five years, market-driven forecasts have led to a stronger fourth quarter for the S&P Retail Select Industry Index. “Given that markets are forward looking, market participants bid up the index during the fourth quarter in anticipation of higher first quarter profits, and then if earnings beat expectations additional gains may be made in the first quarter,” according to the report. 

— Read Top 10 Ridiculous Luxury Christmas Gifts: 2015 on ThinkAdvisor.


© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.