Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards
ThinkAdvisor

Portfolio > ETFs > Broad Market

An Immigrant's Eye-View Of Multicultural Markets

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

As an immigrant, I have endured war in my native Vietnam and an Indonesian resettlement camp before coming to the U.S. I have walked in the footsteps of an immigrant, but I also have worked closely with and studied multicultural markets so as to sensitively approach them with the understanding that certain rules and techniques don’t work as they do in the general market.

Here are some of my insights for the successful engagement of multicultural markets.

Geographic distribution

A stereotype exists regarding where certain multicultural groups live in the United States, but that’s all it is–a stereotype. The reality is that multicultural markets are distributed across the country. Not too long ago, there were recognized geographic Asian and Hispanic markets, one on the East Coast and one on the West.

Both of the largest Asian-American populations can still be found in New York and California, but growing numbers of Asian-Americans also can be found in central and southern regions of the U.S., as Asian-Americans migrate to growing technology, retail and medical professions. The Hispanic markets are experiencing a similar trend with large concentrations on either coast, but increasing numbers in the central and northern United States, gravitating to the growing housing and construction markets.

Evolving segments

Geographic location, though changing, is the only commonality among these groups. All Asians, even those in one geographic area like San Francisco or Boston, cannot be lumped together, nor can all Hispanics. Their expectations and needs differ depending on their country of origin, education, occupation and amount of time spent in the U.S.

My segmentation process begins by organizing multicultural markets into three general groups, including those who: (1) immigrated to the U.S. within the last 15 years; (2) are first-generation or were raised in the U. S.; and (3) are second-generation or were born in the U.S.

Immigrated to the U.S. within the last 15 years–These immigrants generally came to the United States to provide a better future for their children and started from scratch. As many among them have little knowledge of financial products, a direct, simple approach to explaining these solutions would be most effective. And these immigrants are most comfortable doing business in their native language with someone from their own community. This group tends to make emotional rather than logical decisions, and may work through adult children. A good deal of time early in the relationship must be used to build trust.

First generation or raised in the U. S– Raised and educated in the United States, this group of immigrants generally migrated as infants or were born soon after their parents arrived. Generally seeking economic growth, this more acculturated group includes formally educated professionals who have exposure to financial services and products. They also make decisions based on advice from respected family members and friends and on what they have read in both the main-stream and multicultural media.

Preferring to do business within their community with someone from their own generation, this segment requires their planners to be educated on the financial planning process and various products available. Valuing education and the backing of a strong financial institution, they base their purchase decisions less on trust than on respect for the expertise of the financial services professional. And they are willing to go outside of their community to find a representative who meets their criteria.

Second generation or born in the U.S.– Individuals in this group may have family wealth they brought from their native country or earned after immigrating. Having a high degree of sophistication with financial services and products, they already are well-versed in complex planning and strategy and do not need help to understand the process.

Planning and strategy discussions begin sooner and are more involved. Members of this group are not concerned with the ethnicity or gender of the financial services representative with whom they are working, as long as that advisor is professional and is backed by a solid company.

Once understanding where my prospects may fall in this basic segmentation, further stratification occurs along the lines of gender, country of origin, occupation and level of education. Again, the purpose of this process is to determine how best to meet the needs of these clients.

Products

Generally, I have found that whole life insurance meets many of the needs of multicultural populations, but because the experience and expectations of each group differs, so will the way this product needs to be presented. Those who are less familiar with the financial planning process (immigrated 15 years ago or less) generally are more conservative and concerned about protecting their family. So they tend to respond to a less complex presentation, focusing on product guarantees.

First generation multicultural groups are interested in seeing the variety of ways that whole life insurance can function in their financial plan and evaluate which are best for them, for example, as a cash accumulation vehicle for college funding instead of a 529 college savings plan. Second-generation multicultural groups are more interested in complex financial planning involving a total solution that combines whole life with several other products.

Segmentation can provide insight into the Asian and Hispanic markets, but be warned: overgeneralization of these two markets can be disastrous. The best way to determine which segment best fits a multicultural individual is by spending time with him or her. Usually, the first 30 minutes of any appointment will set the direction of the relationship.

Support and flexibility of the home office

An important determinant of success in multicultural markets is the support and flexibility of the company behind the individual financial services professional. From market-specific training, to underwriting procedures and in-language collateral materials, home office support is key. For example, important issues to multicultural groups may include the ability to travel to native countries and increased sensitivity to cultures that are discreet about disclosing income.

These lessons have resulted more from my own experience than from my formal education. But what has worked for me will need to be tested by you, as well. Through trial and error, you can develop your own success in the multicultural market.

Jonathan Phan, CLU, is general agent of the Asset Management Group, a general agency of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co., Springfield, Mass. You can e-mail him at [email protected].


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.