Podcast Center
Video Center
Webcasts
Resource Center
Events
October 26, 2016 at 01:00 AM
Picture this: A website designer creates separate enrollment pages for two groups of 401(k) plan participants. Prompted to select from a list of mutual funds, the first group fills in 8 blank fields; the second group completes 4 fields, but can select additional funds by clicking a link.
This real-world test, conducted on Morningstar.com subscribers, resulted in just 10 percent of group 2 participants choosing more than 4 funds, despite the link. The percentage among Group 1 subjects: quadruple that of group 2.
Related: Software pundit: Plan for a total IT overhaul after DOL rule
An impressive difference indeed, and one highlighted by the experiment’s co-creator, UCLA Professor Shlomo Benartzi, during a keynote talk at a Voya Financial media briefing on October 18. Tapped to head Voya’s new Behavioral Finance Institute for Innovation, Benartzi referenced the research to a make a critical point: Under the Department of Labor’s new conflict of interest rule, plan sponsors and advisors will need to become “digital fiduciaries.”
Acting in the client’s best interest, he said, won’t be just about meeting the rule’s best interest contract requirements. To fulfill the spirit of the DOL rule, plan fiduciaries will need to ensure that websites and planning tools are designed to optimize retirement outcomes for participants.
Engaged in an emerging branch of behavioral finance focused on personal investing, Benartzi has been something of an evangelist for this concept in recent months. Writing in the Harvard Business Review in December 2015, he described the digital responsibilities as follows:
“If the job of a plan fiduciary is to act in the best interest of their plan participants, then research suggests they need to understand how people think and choose in the online world. In the twentieth century, being a fiduciary for employee benefit plans meant having a deep knowledge and expertise of investing. Now, in the twenty-first century, these fiduciaries need to add digital expertise to their skill set.”
Related: Pet project: MassMutual campaign boosts retirement savings
Such expertise would encompass, in particular, an understanding of digital techniques demonstrated to help boost employee enrollment, contribution rates and a diversified allocation of investments in defined contribution plans.
The aforementioned experiment highlights one such technique. Over the course of the two-hour media briefing, Benartzi touch on others, starting with a detailed analysis of how actively engaged (or “reflective”) employees are with the plan portal. To the extent that site interactions denote more “instinctive” behavior (e.g., choosing a savings rate or mutual funds without thinking much about the selection’s financial impact), then adjustments may be needed to improve the result.
