Close
ThinkAdvisor

Regulation and Compliance > Federal Regulation > DOL

Bill Halting DOL Fiduciary Rule to Move Ahead

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

House Financial Services Chairman Jeb Hensarling, R-Texas, said Thursday that he will advance Rep. Ann Wagner’s Retail Investor Protection Act as it “will stop” the Department of Labor’s “misguided” fiduciary rule and require the DOL to defer to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s “expertise” on fiduciary-related issues.

A day after stating that she wants her bill to halt the DOL’s fiduciary redraft marked up by month’s end, Wagner. R-Mo., also said during a joint hearing held Thursday by the House Financial Services Capital Markets and Oversight and Investigations Subcommittees, that Labor Secretary Thomas Perez is violating the Administrative Procedure Act by not reproposing the plan.

Wagner said that statements made to her in an Aug. 7 letter by Perez that DOL would issue a final rule — and not a reproposal — signals DOL is reluctant to revise its redraft to amend the definition of fiduciary under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act. “Based on that, it’s hard to imagine the DOL producing a workable rule based off of this proposal. The divide is just too wide between the two,” she stated on a Wednesday call with reporters.

She noted that Perez’s letter nixing a reproposal was sent to her before DOL held hearings from Aug. 10 to 14 on the redraft. DOL is taking comments on the hearing transcripts until Sept. 24.

Wagner argued during the Thursday hearing that her bill, H.R. 1090, the Retail Investor Protection Act, which requires the DOL to wait to issue a fiduciary rule until the SEC issues its own, is “the proper avenue for further regulation” in the fiduciary area.

But Mercer Bullard, professor of law at the University of Mississippi Law School and founder of Fund Democracy, who testified at the Thursday hearing, told ThinkAdvisor that “there is no APA claim for a failure to repropose” a rulemaking. “The claim would be based on the analysis underlying the final rule, but Rep. Wagner is not interested in the final rule.”

The Financial Planning Coalition — consisting of the Financial Planning Association, the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards and the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors — agreed that DOL “will not violate the APA if it moves straight to a final rule.”

The APA requires that an agency “must give notice of a proposed rulemaking, published in the Federal Register, and, after notice is given, solicit and accept public comments on the rule. Those comments will then be used in the agency’s analysis when promulgating a final rule,” the Coalition said.   Case law, the Coalition continues, ”reflects that even if a final rule contains changes from the proposed rule, it need not undergo a second notice and comment period, even where an agency makes substantial changes from a proposed version.”

Paul Schott-Stevens, president and CEO of the Investment Company Institute, who testified at the hearing, stated that “the worst thing that could happen is that this [DOL] proposal is adopted in its current form.”

Perez has stated publicly that DOL is “flexible” and willing to listen to feedback on how to revise the rule.

Rep. Earl Perlmutter, D-Colo., stated during the Thursday hearing that he has spoken with Perez and that “DOL is willing to listen” to how its redraft needs to be changed. He noted that while he co-sponsored the 2013 version of Wagner’s bill, he couldn’t support the version Wagner reintroduced on Feb. 25. “That train has left the station,” he said. “I’ve been waiting for four years for the SEC to act” on its own fiduciary rulemaking.

Bullard, a supporter of DOL’s fiduciary plan, acknowledged that the SEC should have addressed the fiduciary issue, but has “failed to do so.”

ICI’s Schott-Stevens added that while ICI and its members support the “principle that underlies” DOL’s proposal that all advisors act in the best interest of their clients, “there is deeper expertise at the SEC on these [fiduciary-related] issues, and they should have been to this ball more quickly.”

— Check out Rep. Wagner Wants Bill to Halt DOL Fiduciary Rule Marked Up by Month-End on ThinkAdvisor.