The justices Friday said the Little Sisters of the Poor and potentially hundreds of other religious groups with objections to birth control can instead inform federal officials in writing of their views.
The one-page order, which came without published dissent after more than three weeks of deliberations, represents a compromise on an issue that might have divided the justices along ideological lines. The order will apply while the legal dispute plays out in the lower courts.
The justices said their order “should not be construed as an expression of the court’s views on the merits.”
See also: Supreme Court takes Hobby Lobby case
The nuns argued that the form, along with the requirement that they provide it to their insurance administrator, might eventually trigger contraceptive coverage. That can’t happen under current regulations because the rules exempt some church health-care plans.
“We are delighted that the Supreme Court has issued this order protecting the Little Sisters,” Mark Rienzi, the lead lawyer for the nuns, said in a statement. “The government has lots of ways to deliver contraceptives to people. It doesn’t need to force nuns to participate.”
The Justice Department said the court’s order will have a limited impact.
“This injunction applies only to the plaintiffs and is not a ruling on the merits of their case,” the department said in an e-mail. “And plaintiffs have always been eligible for an accommodation from the contraceptive coverage requirement.”
The action modifies a temporary order issued Dec. 31 by Justice Sonia Sotomayor to allow time for briefing and court review. Sotomayor then referred the matter to the full court for resolution.
Little Sisters, which runs 30 nursing homes across the U.S. and has hundreds of lay employees, sought Supreme Court intervention after a Denver-based federal appeals court refused to shield the group. That followed a federal trial judge’s ruling that the group’s rights weren’t violated.
The 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act requires employers to include birth control in the insurance coverage they provide workers. While the law exempts houses of worship from the contraception requirement, the rules governing other religious groups, including the Little Sisters, are more complicated.
The court later this year will consider another religious- rights battle over the Obamacare requirement that employers cover birth control. The justices will hear arguments March 25 from family-run businesses that say they shouldn’t have to provide some types of contraceptive coverage.
The nuns were seeking an exemption for themselves as well as almost 500 other Catholic groups whose health-care plans are run by the Christian Brothers Employee Benefit Trust.