Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards
ThinkAdvisor
dollar bill with ETF written across

Portfolio > ETFs > Broad Market

At DFA, ETFs Signal End of Exclusivity

X
Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

What You Need to Know

  • DFA mutual funds are offered only through advisors, but its ETFs provide many of the same investments.
  • Exclusivity is not the reason for DFA's success, Dave Nadig says.
  • The firm says it's still focused on advisors and is not marketing its ETFs to the public.

Dimensional Fund Advisors, which offers its mutual funds exclusively through approved financial advisors, has opened access to largely the same investments through its recently expanded exchange-traded fund lineup, experts noted recently.

“DFA ‘gatekeeping’ is over. Advisors who sell on access to DFA will need a new spiel. 99% of DFA’s useful lineup will be unrestricted in the ETF wrapper,” Rubin Miller, advisor and founder at Peltoma Capital Partners,  posted on X in September as Dimensional prepared to launch two new ETFs.

“I can’t wait. I love the funds and I love democratized access for all investors,” Miller, a former DFA regional director and current client, added. “No more barriers to entry,” he said in another post congratulating DFA on its new global stock ETF.

By launching its World Equity ETF and Ultrashort Bond ETF last month, Dimensional, which introduced its first ETFs in 2020, now offers investors access through an ETF “wrapper” to virtually the same assets packaged in its mutual funds, Miller said.

Dimensional in late September announced it was adding seven new ETFs, including the newly listed Ultrashort Fixed Income ETF (NYSE Arca: DUSB) and World Equity ETF (NYSE Arca: DFAW). The company expects to end this year with 38 ETFs and to roll out others in the future.

The two recently added funds had been “glaringly missing” from Dimensional’s ETF offerings, Miller told ThinkAdvisor in a recent interview.

A ‘Simple, Elegant Portfolio’

“The evolving value proposition of advisors is fantastic for investors, and selling ‘access to DFA’ is done. You still want an advisor/financial planner with immense investment expertise, you just want that expertise to be manifested via a simple, elegant portfolio of well-engineered, low cost funds,” Miller posted.

The new World Equity ETF gives investors exposure to the entire global stock market and could constitute a client’s entire stock portfolio, he noted in the interview. Many advisors, wirehouses and brokerages place 100 or more funds in client portfolios, which doesn’t add value, is confusing and “makes people feel dumb,” Miller said. 

“I’m a big believer that not everyone needs an advisor,” Miller said, adding he’s glad to see there’s a solution for them. ”It’s a great example of the democratization of finance.”

DFA’s Real Secret Sauce

Dave Nadig, ETF expert and financial futurist at Vetta Fi, agreed with the idea that investors no longer have to use advisors to access Dimensional investments because they can buy effectively the same assets available in mutual funds through ETFs.

“For a long time, Dimensional’s hook to advisors was exclusivity, and advisors diligently went to Texas to get trained on the Dimensional way. As the ETF lineup continues to expand, it becomes harder and harder to argue there’s any exclusivity left,” although there’s some, as not every Dimensional strategy is in an ETF, Nadig told ThinkAdvisor by email.

“But it’s worth pointing out that the real reason for Dimensional’s success has always been substance, not style. They’ve delivered on their core promise of smarter, low-cost pseudo-passive investing, which remains a pretty unique niche,” one also occupied by Avantis, which was founded by Dimensional’s former co-CEO and chief investment officer, Nadig said.

Miller noted that when Dimensional launched mutual funds decades ago, the firm decided to sell them only through approved advisors who attended their conferences. This exclusivity was a big part of the firm’s success, he said.

DFA wanted long-term, sticky relationships to guard against investors being negatively affected by money moving too quickly in and out of its mutual funds, Miller explained.

ETFs generally offer lower costs, tax advantages and more flexible trading than traditional mutual funds, as they trade like stocks.

For advisors, trading ETFs means they have to participate in the market, whereas mutual fund trades come only at the market day’s end, Miller noted. “That has changed the landscape of what kind of advisor people want,” as they need one who knows how to engage with the market and execute trades, he said.

By Popular Demand

Bryce Skaff, co-head of Dimensional’s global client group, noted that DFA has many more mutual funds than ETFs, as the firm started offering mutual funds four decades ago. Nonetheless, he added, “advisors can fill out an asset allocation with a lot of confidence for investors” with the firm’s ETF offerings.

Dimensional launched its ETFs in response to advisor requests, he told ThinkAdvisor in an interview Tuesday. “They wanted one more tool in addition to Dimensional mutual funds.”

On the legacy mutual fund side, “our approach has always been about arming great advisors with the tools and resources they need to make great decisions for investors,” and the firm’s conferences and other resources that are important to its advisor relationships remain intact “regardless of the wrapper,” Skaff added.

The uptake in Dimensional ETFs has been “fantastic,” and those funds now have about $100 billion in assets under management, he said. The firm guides investors to work with approved advisors and doesn’t promote its ETF offerings to the public, Skaff added.

“Our objective was always to be in service of financial advisors to do good work for investors,” he said.

Dimensional has a list of other potential ETF categories to offer in the future, Skaff said.

Image: Adobe Stock


NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.