50 States of Data for the Third Wave of COVID-19

The third wave of COVID-19 cases appears to be starting to fill hospital beds in the Dakotas, Mississippi, Montana and Wisconsin, but the overall U.S. death rate appears to be holding steady.

COVID-19 was causing about 2,400 deaths per day during the first wave, which peaked in April, and about 1,300 deaths per day during the second wave, which peaked in August, according to death data compiled by The COVID Tracking Project at The Atlantic.

During the current wave, the number of deaths may still be averaging fewer than 1,000 per day.

The relatively low number of deaths could be due partly to data collection problems and data reporting delays, partly to improvements in COVID-19 treatment methods, and partly to the nature of COVID-19: Deaths from COVID-19 tend to occur about two to eight weeks after people start to have COVID-19 symptoms, according to researchers at Harvard.

Resources

The Dynata COVID-19 symptom maps and charts are available here.
The mSightly COVID-19 data dashboard is available here.
The COVID Tracking Project at The Atlantic is available here.
The Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center numbers are available here.
The CDC’s weekly COVID-19 report is available here.
The HHS hospital capacity data is available here.
An overview article about the COVID-19 data for the previous week is available here.

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) also reports daily death counts quickly, but it takes weeks to process and revise mortality data.

The most recent week that appears to have reasonably complete death data is the week ending Sept. 12. In that week, 24 states had total death counts that were at least 10% higher than the expected level, compared with 35 states that had death counts at least 10% higher than the expected level in the week ending Aug. 22.

The CDC bases the expected death counts for a week on the average number of deaths reported in a state for the comparable week in the year in the previous three years.

For the week ending Sept. 12, the total number of deaths from all causes was about 6% higher than the expected number.

The United States normally averages about 2.7 million deaths per year.

The country has recorded about 220,000 deaths resulting directly from COVID-19, as of today. If mortality stayed at 6% over the usual level for the rest of the year, then the country might experience about 36,000 additional excess deaths as a result of COVID-19 and related problems, such as the effects of COVID-19 on patients’ willingness to seek care for conditions other than COVID-19.

The catastrophic 1918 influenza pandemic caused about 600,000 deaths, in a population of 100 million.

Another well-known flu pandemic, the 1968 Hong Kong flu pandemic, caused about 120,000 deaths in a population of about 200 million.

One CDC indicator that suggests that COVID-19 morality could stay high is the ratio of deaths caused by COVID-19 and illnesses that look like COVID-19 — pneumonia and influenza — to all deaths. That indicator continues to be well above the epidemic threshold for the week, in spite of data reporting problems that tend to make the ratio look lower than it really is for several weeks after the death numbers start coming in.

The Dynata Data

Dynata, a data firm, powers many website instant survey programs. In place of its regular surveys, it serves some site users a COVID-19 symptom survey.

The company than feeds the survey data into a free, public — but copyrighted — tracking dashboard. The company can’t be certain whether the people who report having COVID-19-like symptoms actually have COVID-19 or some other health problem, but, while COVID-19 appears to be a common viral infection, reports of people having those symptoms could be an early sign of the intensity of COVID-19 activity in a given region.

One question has been what the return of students to colleges, universities and other schools might do COVID-19 infection rates.

The percentage of U.S. Dynata survey participants ages 18 to 24 who said they had a dry cough with loss of the sense of smell or taste was 3% for the two-week period ending Oct. 16. That’s same as the percentage of U.S. college-age respondents who told Dynata they had COVID-19-like symptoms for the two-week period ending Sept. 25.

But the number of states where 3.5% or more of the college-age Dynata survey takers said they had COVID-19-like symptoms increased to at least 11 as of Oct. 16, from four for the two-week period ending Sept. 25.

That state count excludes some states for which Dynata has fewer than 50 responses for people ages 18 to 24.

When the minimum reporting count is set at one, the number of states with COVID-19-like symptom rates higher than 3.5% for college-age Dynata survey respondents increases to 13 for the latest period, from seven three weeks earlier.

The national percentage may have stayed about the same because the states where the symptom rate is spiking are low-population states: The college-age survey taker symptom rates were highest in South Dakota, Alaska and Oklahoma. Only 19 college-age people in South Dakota responded to Dynata’s symptom survey, but four of those respondents said they had COVID-19-like symptoms.

In Alaska, one of the nine college-age survey takers had COVID-19-like symptoms.

Some COVID-19 trackers have suggested that the 80th Sturgis Motorcycle Rally, which started Aug. 7 in Sturgis, South Dakota, may be leading to a spike in COVID-19 cases in the Dakotas and other states in the middle of the country.

Among U.S. states with at least 100 college-age Dynata respondents, the state with the highest COVID-19-like symptom rate is South Carolina. About 6.9% of the college-age Dynata respondents in South Carolina have been suffering from COVID-19-like symptoms. Only 0.6% of the South Carolina Dynata respondents in other age groups have been having COVID-19-like symptoms.

The ThinkAdvisor Campus COVID-19 Dashboard Tracker

Some colleges and universities have developed COVID-19 test result tracking dashboards.

The dashboards have been getting some attention, because some epidemiologists have feared that colleges could have problems with social distancing, and that weak social distancing could lead to a big fall COVID-19 wave.

A look at 18 colleges and universities with daily test result reporting shows that, on Oct. 16, the schools with the daily reporting dashboards seemed to be much better at controlling COVID-19 than they were on Sept. 25.

For the 18 colleges and universities in the sample, the total number of tests reported fell to 30,983, from 32,574,. The number of samples found to show signs of COVID-19 fell to 138, from 289.

The percentage of test samples found to show signs of COVID-19 fell to, 0.4%, from 0.9%.

If the dashboard figures are accurate,, they could suggest that schools with rigorous COVID-19 testing and infection control programs have a good chance to minimize the number of people on campus who get COVID-19.

(as of Sept. 12)
Ratio of All Reported Deaths to Expected Deaths
State	COVID-19 Deaths	Pneumonia, Influenza, or COVID-19 Deaths	Total Deaths	Total Deaths as % of Expected Deaths
Alabama	128	103	1,144	1.19
Alaska	NA	NA	62	0.78
Arizona	60	86	1,258	1.19
Arkansas	97	83	706	1.15
California	511	577	5,773	1.22
Colorado	33	53	839	1.14
Connecticut	NA	13	383	0.67
Delaware	NA	11	181	1.08
District of Columbia	NA	13	117	1.03
Florida	516	563	4,479	1.17
Georgia	238	201	1,809	1.15
Hawaii	32	30	269	1.14
Idaho	25	19	320	1.24
Illinois	118	131	2,062	1.04
Indiana	85	111	1,248	1.03
Iowa	58	49	610	1.11
Kansas	51	37	568	1.19
Kentucky	67	85	917	1.02
Louisiana	103	89	865	0.98
Maine	NA	19	317	1.16
Maryland	37	45	983	1.09
Massachusetts	22	42	1,005	0.93
Michigan	37	90	1,901	1.08
Minnesota	56	43	847	1.03
Mississippi	107	87	706	1.2
Missouri	144	100	1,255	1.06
Montana	22	21	215	1.16
Nebraska	21	24	325	1.03
Nevada	57	69	526	1.13
New Hampshire	NA	NA	227	0.97
New Jersey	34	69	1,375	1.04
New Mexico	NA	19	343	1.04
New York	25	136	1,767	1
New York City	17	68	959	0.98
North Carolina	0	NA	15	0.01
North Dakota	12	10	141	1
Ohio	140	159	2,435	1.06
Oklahoma	68	83	751	1.03
Oregon	22	29	707	1.1
Pennsylvania	87	109	2,386	0.97
Rhode Island	NA	10	186	0.98
South Carolina	140	109	1,174	1.3
South Dakota	20	12	165	1.06
Tennessee	178	182	1,673	1.2
Texas	519	478	4,419	1.2
Utah	12	23	378	1.11
Vermont	0	NA	113	1.13
Virginia	113	85	1,411	1.14
Washington	31	71	1,137	1.13
West Virginia	19	NA	97	0.23
Wisconsin	47	49	1,052	1.05
Wyoming	NA	NA	118	1.31
United States	4,155	4,523	54,719	1.06

School	Location	Tests	Positive	% Positive, Oct. 16	% Positive, Sept. 25
U.S. University COVID-19 Case Tracker (Results for Oct. 16)
Arizona, University of	Tucson, Arizona	952	6	0.6%	3.4%
California at Berkeley, University of	Berkeley, California	682	1	0.1%	0.1%
Colorado, University of	Boulder, Colorado	864	1	0.1%	8.0%
George Washington University	District of Columbia	268	0	0.0%	0.0%
Illinois, University of	Urbana-Champaign	9,700	9	0.1%	0.4%
Lasell University	Newton, Massachusetts	516	0	0.0%	0.0%
Massachusetts Institute of Technology	Cambridge, Massachusetts	3,780	1	0.0%	0.0%
Miami, University of	Coral Gables, Florida	204	14	6.9%	0.5%
Michigan Technological University	Houghton, Michigan	20	0	0.0%	2.2%
Nebraska-Lincoln, University of	Lincoln, Nebraska	275	18	6.5%	9.3%
Ohio State University	Columbus, Ohio	2,967	23	0.8%	1.3%
Rhode Island School of Design	Providence, Rhode Island	99	0	0.0%	0.0%
Rice University	Houston	983	0	0.0%	0.2%
State University of New York system	Various	4,039	36	0.9%	0.7%
Tulane University	New Orleans	1,763	6	0.3%	1.7%
Wisconsin, University of	Madison, Wisconsin	1,664	18	1.1%	1.3%
Yale University	New Haven, Connecticut	2,207	5	0.2%	0.1%
AVERAGE		30,983	138	0.4%	0.9%