Close Close

Financial Planning > Behavioral Finance

3 Reasons Financial Wellness Might Sting

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

Two new financial wellness reports contain sobering thoughts for workers and employers, and the financial professionals who serve them.

Prudential Financial Inc. has published a guide to financial wellness programs by two of the company’s top executives. Financial Finesse Inc. has released a report on optimizing financial wellness programs for a diverse workforce.

Typical medical wellness program reports give straightforward analyses of how conditions such as obesity and diabetes affect employees’ health, and employers’ benefits costs, and how employers can use the right kinds of programs to lower benefits costs and increase productivity. Labor groups have raised some questions about wellness program fairness and privacy issues, but most players have agreed on the need to resolve the concerns and keep wellness programs in operation.

(Related: EEOC Updates Wellness Rules) 

Many financial wellness program reports have taken a similar upbeat approach to the topic.

The authors of the Prudential and Financial Finesse reports give similar information, but they also take on some difficult questions related to worker demographics.

Here’s a look at three reasons the reports are more serious than they sound.

1. The growing focus on financial wellness is a symptom of financial stress.

The concept of financial wellness has been around since at least as far back as the early 1990s, when J. Grady Cash trademarked the term and used it as the name for a financial planning firm he ran in Hampton, Virginia. The topic really took off in the employee benefits community around 2012, when Aflac Inc. reported that fewer than half of the workers it surveyed had at least $1,000 in savings they could use to cover unexpected medical expenses.

Today, many more insurers are putting financial wellness in the spotlight.

One reason is that surveys show that many Americans’ finances are in terrible shape. Christine Marcks, president of Prudential Retirement, and Andrew Sullivan, president of Prudential Group Insurance, write in the Prudential report that fewer than 40% of Americans have enough savings in a rainy day fund to cover a $500 emergency.

Only 22% of the individuals who participated in a recent Prudential survey said they felt financially secure, Marcks and Sullivan write.

Pig in a vise (Image: Thinkstock)

(Image: Thinkstock)

A second reason for insurers to focus on wellness is pressure from the U.S. Department of Labor and other state and federal agencies to base investment product recommendations on what workers really need. Financial wellness questionnaires can help insurers that are selling annuities, retirement plan administration services and related products and services understand what workers need.

A third reason is that insurers can sell financial wellness analysis services without worrying about the effects of low interest rates on their general account portfolio yields. Low yields are squeezing the profitability of interest-sensitive products such as guaranteed investment contracts and disability insurance. Offering financial wellness analysis services is a way to generate revenue that’s not correlated with interest rates.

2. Some employers might be interested in financial wellness programs because, frankly, they want workers of a certain age to leave.

Some workers now think of working past the age of 65 as a good way to make Social Security benefits and retirement savings last longer.

Government commissions around the world are trying to think of ways to persuade more employers to keep older workers on the job.

Marcks and Sullivan show in their report that, from the perspective of the employer, delayed worker retirement is a problem.

“Employees who are unable to retire on time may experience higher stress levels, a lack of engagement and lower productivity,” the Prudential executives write. “Their delayed retirement may also result in turnover of younger employees due to lack of upward mobility.”

The cost of a three-year delay in retirement for a private-sector worker amounts to 3.6% of total compensation, according to Marcks and Sullivan. That’s comparable to the cost of offering workers paid vacation time, the executives write.

3. A financial wellness program could lead to difficult conversations.

Financial Finesse makes another potentially controversial point: Financial stress levels may have a correlation with employee demographics.

Financial Finesse sells web-based financial education programs for employees to employers.

Puzzle (Image: Thinkstock)

(Image: Thinkstock)

The company analyzed employee financial stress data for the new report by reviewing the financial wellness questionnaires customers’ employees completed in 2016.

The company gave each employee a financial stress score, and put the employees in five different stress level categories, ranging from Suffering to Secure.

The company also came up with an estimate of how much employees’ level of financial stress might cost, or benefit, the employer each year.

Having an employee in the Suffering category might cost an employer about $198 per year, according to the analysis, while each employee in the Secure category might lead to $143 in employer gains per year.

One challenge for an employer that wants to address the effects of financial stress on its productivity, and maximize the financial gains resulting from financial security, is that average financial stress levels appear to vary with ethnicity.

Financial Finesse came up with separate sets of figures for the new report for workers who described themselves as being Asian-American, Caucasian, Hispanic or African-American.

The firm found, for example, that the percentage of workers in its Suffering category ranged from 3% for Asian-American workers to 14% for African-American workers.

When the firm broke out data only for workers with annual income ranging from $60,000 to $100,000, the financial stress level figures still followed the same pattern. The Asian-American workers in that income category received the lowest financial stress scores, and the workers in other ethnic groups received higher financial stress scores.

That suggests that any financial wellness efforts that lead to questions about privacy or fairness for workers facing financial stress could also lead to questions about fairness for workers in different ethnic groups.

— Read Buerger: Life Settlement Industry Must Evolve on ThinkAdvisor.