Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards

Portfolio > Investment VIPs

China’s ponzi-dodging pensioners chase high returns, free lunch

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

(Bloomberg) — Little-known private investment firms have been popping up all over China, luring pensioners’ savings by promising annual returns of more than 10 percent, and sometimes as high 60 percent, to fund cash-thirsty projects unable to get bank loans.

Distributing fliers outside supermarkets and drawing on word-of-mouth, the private firms ­— part of China’s unregulated network of shadow financing-— typically lure retirees with the offer of free lunch. A recent feast of radish soup, spare ribs, red-cooked pork, fried vegetables and a yogurt cup at a downtown Beijing restaurant drew about 100 mostly elderly people to hear a passionate lecture on the importance of investing.

Attendees were treated to a magic show in which a magician chopped off the hand of his assistant in a bloody flourish, a bamboo flute concert, a whirling acrobat, and lucky drawings — as well as the promise of 12 percent annual returns to lend their money to a real estate project in Chengdu.

“The project sounds not bad, just the return is a bit low,” said Fan, a blasé 62-year-old attendee who only gave her surname. She does this all the time and normally expects higher rates, no less than 15 percent on average, she said.

That’s low compared with other investments being touted to Beijing’s elderly. A typical supermarket flier will list several offers with returns in the low double-digits. When potential investors phone up, they’re offered higher rates for even riskier products. A recent one, to fund the acquisition of a small oil pipe company in Jilin province, promised 5 percent a month, or 60 percent annually.

Be Wary

The risk that some will turn out to be Ponzi schemes and never pay back the principal propels the wisest of the elderly investors to be wary. They advise each other to attend only investment pitches with lower returns, eat the free lunch on offer and take their money out relatively quickly before any signs of repayment difficulties emerge.

Another lunch attendee who only gave her surname as Wang said her self-imposed cutoff for investments is a 20 percent annual return, and that she makes site trips to see projects herself whenever possible. She knows two people who put money into a product offering more than 30 percent last year, only to see their investments sour after receiving just two monthly payments, she said.

“My experience is, don’t stick with any company for too long,” Wang said, as the emcee loudly read out names of people who he proclaimed had just collectively pledged more than 2 million yuan (about $313,800) to fund the Chengdu project.

While it’s possible for experienced investors to make money from investments that turn out to be Ponzi schemes, the risk is like “pulling chestnuts out of the fire,” said Liao Qiang, a Beijing-based analyst for Standard & Poor’s.

Least Transparent

China’s 147 million pensioners are plowing more of their money into investments other than deposits. Net inflows into open-end mutual funds jumped 32-fold from a year earlier to 1 trillion yuan last year, according to a June report from the Asset Management Association of China. While investors older than 60 accounted for only 9 percent of all such accounts, their average investment of 42,800 yuan as of Dec. 31 was the highest among all age groups, compared to 8,100 yuan among people younger than 30, according to the report.

As China’s massive market selloff leaves many Chinese jittery about stocks, little-known investment companies have proliferated, prompting authorities to try to crack down with little result. China’s lowering of interest rates paid by banks four times this year, as well as a tightening of lending to riskier projects, is also fueling growth.

‘Informal lending’

“This informal lending segment of the shadow banking system is one of the least transparent and regulated, and is likely to be among the most risky for investors,” said Stephen Schwartz, a Hong Kong-based senior vice president at Moody’s Investors Service. “Based on anecdotal information, we understand that this activity has become more widespread in the past year or two.”

Demand for loans is unrequited in a country where the shadow banking system, which includes all lending outside banks, has already grown to an estimated 41 trillion yuan at the end of last year, equivalent to 65 percent of gross domestic product, according to Moody’s. Small businesses and unrated property developers are likely “encountering tighter financing conditions” as increased government scrutiny slows the growth of core channels such as trust loans, the rating firm said in a July report

Violating Rules

While many of the investment companies are registered asset managers with offices in high-rise downtown buildings, they risk violating a government rule banning any marketing of private products to the general public.

Under current rules, private investment products can only be sold to qualified investors that have at least 500,000 yuan average annual income in the past three years, no promise on repayment of principal or yield is allowed, and investment in a single product shouldn’t be lower than 1 million yuan. Often the qualification requirements are skipped, high returns committed, and investments of as small as 50,000 yuan welcomed, according to investors interviewed by Bloomberg News.

While shadow financing keeps growing, the government has rarely taken the initiative to “burst the bubble,” and any efforts tend to be just after-risk remedies unable to prevent losses, said Liao.

“I feel that regulatory and law enforcement authorities are somewhat out of step with the changes in the financial market,” Liao said. “It’s quite a pity from the perspective of both financial stability and investor protection.”

Government Crackdown

The government’s pursuit of illegal fundraising cases in Beijing more than tripled to 89 in 2014 from the previous year, with investors affected nationwide jumping six-fold to 21,000 and investments involved skyrocketing 57 times to 17.3 billion yuan, according to official data from city authorities. Such cases continued to surge 65 percent in the first five months of this year, the government said.

That prompted the local government in May to launch a four- month crackdown on illegal fundraising, saying in an April 30 statement that such cases have been frequently found in areas of private investment funds, online lending and wealth management, causing “huge losses” and “serious impact on social order.”

Among the cases was a private investment company known as Cheng Ji Da Yi, a familiar name among investors after its financing director disappeared with client money late last year, according to police statements then.

The risks are hardly enough to stop investors from seeking high returns that traditional channels can’t offer. Five interest rate cuts since November reduced the appeal of banks’ wealth management products, and returns available through peer-to-peer online lending, which fell to 13 percent in August, pale in the face of private products.

Raising Pensions

“I’m entering middle age, and I’ll need to do some investing,” said a 32-year-old former drug store saleswoman who only gave her surname as Jiao, after attending a presentation that promoted a strawberry-growing and tourism project in neighboring Hebei province that promised a 36 percent return.

Beijing raised the average pension for the city’s 2.3 million retired enterprise workers, covering all company workers including state-owned enterprises, to 3,355 yuan a month this year, compared with the national average of 2,061 yuan in 2014.

“I’ve looked at more than 20 projects, and this one sounds good,” Jiao said outside the central Beijing office tower where the 100 million yuan product was presented to about 10 potential investors. The 12 percent she’s been getting from her P2P investments is “too low,” she said. 

‘Disorderly and Covert’

A Sept. 1 relaxation of a ceiling on private-lending interest rates by the Supreme People’s Court reflects the borrowers and lenders’ “real needs,” the court said. Previously the cap was four times the benchmark lending rate, which would mean 18.4 percent for one-year loans at today’s level. Now, only interest in excess of 36 percent will be invalid, and borrowing among non-financial companies will be “conditionally recognized,” according to the court, which said it was responding to small businesses’ “thirst for sunshine financing and legitimate investments.”

While private lending is a “reasonable supplement” to regular financing, lack of supervision and its “blind, disorderly and covert” development has led to a doubling in related disputes in four years to 1.02 million cases last year, according to the top court. Such cases are often intertwined with those of fundraising fraud and unlawfully taking public deposits, it said.

Getting your money back early and steering clear of exceptionally high returns, according to some investors, is the key to avoiding losses.

“I’ve been investing like this since 2002 and I never lost money,” Wang said. “Just don’t be too greedy.”


© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.