Close Close

Portfolio > Mutual Funds > Target Date Funds

Misused TDFs negatively impacting returns

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

Participants in 401(k)s who get professional investment help through managed accounts, target-date funds or online advice earn higher median annual returns than those who go it alone, new research shows.

Financial Engines and Aon Hewitt reveal this finding in “Help in Defined Contribution Plans: 2006 through 2012,” a study that examines the 401(k) investing behavior of 723,000 workers at 14 large U.S. employers. The report draws conclusions from seven years of data within the defined contribution plans of 14 companies, representing 723,000 individuals and more than $55 billion in plan assets.

The report shows that, on average, employees using professional investment help had median annual returns that are 3.32 percent higher, net of fees, than participants managing their own portfolios. If two participants — one securing professional assistance and the other not — both invest $10,000 at age 45, assuming both participants receive the median returns identified in the report, the assisted participant could have 79 percent more wealth at age 65 ($58,700) than the non-aided participant ($32,800), the report indicates.

“We recognize that many workers benefit from some professional assistance with their investing,” explained Rob Austin, director of retirement research at Aon Hewitt. “Help can significantly impact workers’ long-term savings outlook by giving them the resources they need to make smarter investment decisions. The key is to use [help] in a way that maximizes results.”

The study finds that more than 60 percent of workers who hold money in target-date funds also invest in other funds. Among partial target-date fund users, the average allocation to target-date funds was just 35 percent.

“When employees fail to invest in [target-date funds] exclusively, they often end up undermining the benefits of these funds, which are controlling risk and providing good diversification,” says Wei-Yin Hu, vice president of financial research at Financial Engines. “Improper use occurs for a variety of reasons, including an employer matching in company stock, workers attempting to time the market, or a lack of understanding of how target-date funds work. Participants may also simply be averse to putting all of their money in one fund as their balance grows.”

Target-date fund misuse is hurting investment returns. The study finds that, on average, workers who were partially allocated to target date funds had median annual returns that were 2.11 percent lower, net of fees, than individuals exclusively using target date funds and 2.61 percent lower than those in managed accounts.

See also:


© 2023 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.