A vote for independence from the U.K. in Scotland scheduled for September 2014 could pave the way for a new currency—or not, depending on whom you ask.
The Scottish government, led by the Scottish National Party, issued a 670-page “blueprint for independence” at the end of November that called for many changes—but for an independent Scotland to retain the pound sterling as its currency. However, opposition parties, and London officials, have said keeping the pound is not possible for many reasons.
The British government has said it is not likely to agree to Scotland’s retention of the currency, citing issues such as lack of political unity and pointing to the eurozone and its woes as an example of the problems that can ensue when independent political entities share a currency. However, believers have said that London will eventually recognize reality and give in—or that, if it refuses to share, Edinburgh may walk away from its share of the U.K.’s debt.
While there are plenty of other issues of major importance that must be decided should Scotland decide to go it alone, such as whether the newly independent country will still be a member of the European Union—opinions differ on that as well, particularly since Spain would not be likely to welcome a split-off Scotland over fears that its own rebellious Catalonia would follow suit and seek its own independence—the currency issue is one that’s getting a lot of folks on both sides of the issue hot under the collar.
What Your Peers Are Reading
Alex Salmond, Scotland’s first minister, has insisted that not only would the country keep the pound, but the Bank of England would still come to the rescue if Scottish banks needed a bailout. But British Prime Minister David Cameron called the possibility of Scottish retention of the pound unlikely. Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne has said that London was not likely to share its currency with an independent country, and Sir John Major, former British prime minister, said during a London speech that “Independence means Scotland walking away from the U.K. and its institutions. This must include the Bank of England and sterling.”
Others have said that whether or not Scotland wants to retain the pound, Northern Ireland, Wales and, of course, England would have the final vote on the matter. Mark Carney, governor of the Bank of England, has said that he’s willing to hold currency talks with Salmond to explore the issue.
Currency traders are supporting the notion of a shared pound, with both Deutsche Bank AG and Citigroup Inc. saying the notion makes sense because of the way Scotland is connected to the British economy.
Fitch Ratings, which explored the possible effects of an independent Scotland on the residual U.K. late in 2012, has not changed its basic position, according to Peter Fitzpatrick, Fitch spokesman. He pointed out that at that time, Fitch said it could not take a stab at rating an independent Scotland because of so many variables, including the question of currency. However, it could and did review how such an event might affect what would be left of the U.K. after such a split.