Close Close

Regulation and Compliance > Federal Regulation

Speakers Warn Of Over-Regulation

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

WASHINGTON — Independent agents here at a conference heard Sen. Jon Tester, D-Mont., voice strong support for state insurance regulation.

Republican speakers at the conference, who discussed health care, said policymakkers who are trying to reform the health care system should avoid overregulation.

The conference was organized by the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America, Washington.

Tester, a member of the Senate Appropriations Committee, told agents that the economic crisis has shown the necessity for regulatory reform of the financial industry, but he added that Congress must not overact and must make commonsense decisions.

Insurance, Tester said, is one industry that does not need a federal overhaul, because the state regulators have played a “critical role” in ensuring that the fate of other financial institutions did not befall insurers.

He said his time as a state legislator in Montana taught him how effectively state regulators can oversee the insurance industry.

“Having served at the state level, I feel that regulation of the insurance industry should be handled at that level just as it has been for the last 140 years,” he declared, adding that expanding the reach of the federal government is not always the answer.

Regulations must be put in place to allow federal regulators to prevent the massive financial failures of large conglomerates, such as American International Group Inc., New York, and reforms of the insurance industry should streamline the agent licensing process and improve regulation covering flood and crop insurance, he said.

Tester compared regulators to referees on a basketball court. Regulators should set the ground rules for play and then get out of the way, only to step-in when those rules are violated, he said.

The senator also touched on health care reform, saying that it is something that needs to be done, but he did not say what reforms should look like. Responding to a question, he said changes would not be done by one party alone and need to include a range of ideas.

“No one is going to ram anything down anyone’s throat,” he said, adding that whatever is done must be affordable and accessible for all Americans, but emphasizing that it will get done.

Addressing the same group earlier, House Republican Whip Rep. Eric Cantor, Va., said health care reform is necessary, but that there are two visions of reform.

One vision calls for a federal plan to take over the system, while the Republican vision would create a system that still preserves accessibility to health services and patient’s choice, Cantor said. He said health care should not become a “bureaucratic nightmare.”

Discussing regulation in general, Cantor said the role of the federal government should be to help small business entrepreneurs prosper, “not burdening them” with regulations.

He said agents who plan to visit their representatives on Capital Hill today need to make a stand against over-regulation.

“The attempts to over-regulate are real and you have the opportunity to prevent that,” he said.

His comments echoed those of Chief Deputy Republican Whip Rep. Kevin McCarthy, Calif., who told a group of agents that decisions on health care reform would probably be made in the next few months and that he opposed ideas being proposed by President Barack Obama and congressional Democrats. He said the health care system they would create would be neither compassionate nor efficient.


© 2023 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.