Is Now a Good Time to Retire?

Expert Opinion April 10, 2024 at 09:25 PM
Share & Print

What You Need To Know

  • It is never good to be forced to sell into a down market.
  • A severe downturn can decimate clients' retirement portfolios if it occurs late in their working years or early in retirement.
  • It makes sense to begin raising cash in clients' portfolios to fund the early years of retirement on a gradual basis.
Senior couple, clock, money bag, saving jar on steps of rising coins

Most clients will rely on investments to fund a significant portion of their retirement income needs. Managing all aspects of their investments as they approach and enter retirement is a key part of the work that advisors do for these clients.

This is a major contributor to their quality of life in retirement. 

Looking back to the financial crisis from mid-2007 through early 2009, we saw a number of retirees and near-retirees suffer portfolio losses that hindered their ability to retire. Market timing as clients head into retirement and through their early retirement years is a very valid concern. 

When to Retire?

This has always been a key question for clients approaching retirement, though it is less clear cut these days as many people choose to phase into retirement rather than retiring "cold turkey" as was prevalent in past generations. 

Whether a full cessation of work or something more gradual, planning for the timing of clients' retirement is key in many respects. This includes when to claim Social Security or pension benefits and a host of other decisions. 

Managing their investment portfolio into retirement is critical. How should their assets be allocated? What happens if the market takes a major hit just as they are looking to retire? 

Is Now a Good Time to Retire?

Obviously, the answer to this question depends on factors that are specific to a client's overall situation. But in terms of the market environment, this would likely be considered a good time to retire. 

Major market indexes like the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average are at or near all-time highs. Clients who need to liquidate equity holdings to build a cash reserve to fund retirement income distributions over the next couple of years will likely be able to sell many holdings at or near historically high levels. 

This could be a market high point depending on what happens over the next year or so. This isn't a prediction that the markets are going to fall, but we are in an election year. Even though markets generally rise in an election year, there is a lot going on in 2024. In addition to the election, we have: 

  • The direction of interest rates
  • Inflation worries
  • World events such as the wars in the Middle East and Ukraine  

Sequence of Returns Risk

Sequence of returns risk refers to the risk that a significant negative market return will occur late in clients' working years or early in their retirement years. During the financial crisis, there were many stories about retirees or those nearing retirement whose portfolios were decimated just as investors needed to take distributions from their investment accounts. 

This is the ultimate "double whammy" for their retirement savings. These folks sold assets that had dropped in value, so they needed to sell more shares than they otherwise might have. This left a smaller number of investment shares to benefit from the recovery that ultimately followed, putting many of these retirees in tough financial shape. 

There were cases where retirees were forced to delay retirement due to portfolio losses or to go back to work in order to make ends meet.

One key issue is the need to liquidate assets to raise cash in the face of a steep market decline. This can be devastating to a client's retirement portfolio, in some cases severely limiting the longevity of retirement assets. 

Those retiring into a strong market environment will have the advantage of growth in the remaining equity portion of their portfolio, even as they liquidate some assets to fund retirement income distributions over their first few years of retirement. 

Planning vs. Market Timing

Sometimes retiring into a market headwind like the financial crisis cannot be avoided. However, this doesn't mean that clients need to be at the mercy of the stock market in the year they decide to retire. This is where advice and expertise come in. 

There are a number of strategies and tactics to employ as clients near retirement. Proper diversification across an entire portfolio is important; a highly concentrated portfolio is susceptible to market-timing risk. 

Plan Early

As clients approach their anticipated retirement, this is the time to plan and adjust for their cash flow and growth needs. There is no magic number in terms of timeframe, but generally anywhere from two to five years before retirement might be a good time to make portfolio adjustments to help ensure a smooth transition. 

This type of proactive planning can help mitigate the damaging impact a sudden market decline can have on clients' ability to retire comfortably. 

Short-Term Liquidity Needs 

A portion of a client's retirement portfolio should contain funds that are reasonably liquid and largely not subject to the whims of the stock market. This is money that will be needed over a one- or two-year period for living expenses.

One way to start building this portfolio bucket might be through distributions from stocks, mutual funds, exchange-traded funds and other holdings. Be sure this money is distributed as cash rather than reinvested. 

Money to satisfy short-term needs should be held in both taxable investment accounts and inside retirement accounts like IRAs. This can help protect clients against having to liquidate long-term holdings like stocks into a market downturn to fund short-term retirement needs.

Typically, this short-term money would be held in a money market fund or savings account. With interest rates at current levels, building this retirement bucket a bit early can be even more advantageous. 

Intermediate & Long-Term Needs

A portion of a retirement portfolio should be allocated to moderate risk investments to fund clients' needs three to five years out. In today's interest rate environment, short- to intermediate-term bonds might work. Bond or CD ladders can be a good strategy. This bucket might also include moderate to low-risk dividend stocks. 

The long-term portion of their portfolio should include stocks and other growth investments. This is money needed to ensure the long-term viability of their retirement portfolio to meet their lifetime needs. 

Other Considerations

Advisors will need to work around clients' individual circumstances to help achieve their retirement income goals while mitigating potential market risk. 

  • Factor their Social Security and any pensions into estimates of their annual retirement income needs.
  • Consider an annuity if feasible. In the current interest rate environment, a fixed, deferred annuity can be a solid hedge against stock market fluctuations. This can include taking advantage of the higher qualified longevity annuity contract limits under the Secure 2.0 Act for clients who are eligible to use such a contract. 

Conclusion

For clients who haven't done the proper upfront planning and portfolio adjustments in the years heading into retirement to hedge against the impact of a severe decline, market timing can affect a client's ability to retire.

While not advocating market timing, taking advantage of higher markets as clients near retirement can help mitigate sequence of return risk and other related market risks. 


Roger Wohlner is a seasoned financial writer for several publications, who also ghostwrites extensively for financial advisors, financial services providers and investment managers. He has over 20 years of experience as a financial advisor.

(Image: Adobe Stock) 

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Related Stories

Resource Center