After suffering from debilitating headaches for years, Brittany Maynard went to the doctor several months ago to see what was wrong with her. It turned out she had a brain tumor that required immediate removal. After surgery, she underwent a follow-up visit, only to find that the tumor had grown much larger than before, and was now considered a Stage 4 glioblastoma. It was just about the worst form of brain cancer one could be diagnosed with.
Prior to surgery, doctors had given Maynard a prognosis of several years more to live. After discovery of the tumor’s growth, however, they shortened Maynard’s life expectancy to only a few more months. Brain tumors of this type are, essentially, a death sentence for those who have them, and even aggressive treatment typically does no more than extend life expectancy from three months to 15 months. Even then, such treatment tends to bring with it potentially debilitating side effects and expose the patient to prolonged suffering.
Faced with this prognosis, Maynard decided that on Nov. 1, the day after her husband’s birthday, she would take a prescription medication and end her life, rather than endure acute suffering. To do this, she moved from California to Oregon, which has a Death with Dignity law that allows for physician-assisted suicide for patients such as Brittany, who seek to terminate their own life when faced with terminal illness. Washington, Montana, New Mexico and Vermont all have similar laws allowing for physician-assisted suicide.
On Nov. 1, Maynard made good on her plan and ended her life in her home, surrounded by a close circle of family and friends, one of whom was a physician.
What Your Peers Are Reading
In the months before she died, Maynard did two things. One was to travel extensively with her family and check off a number of items on her “bucket list,” including seeing the Grand Canyon. The other was to lend her story to the right-to-die movement, for which she became a highly visible proponent. Since the final passage of Oregon’s right-to-die law in 2013, more than 750 people have opted to end their lives when their death appeared to be inevitable and imminent. The average age of these suicides is 71.
The nature of Maynard’s terminal illness and her decision to end her life was not particularly unusual. That she was so young and photogenic, however, was, and she used that to promote the cause of letting people die on their own terms when their death appears inevitable and imminent.
Before she died, she issued a final statement through Facebook:
“Goodbye to all my dear friends and family that I love. Today is the day I have chosen to pass away with dignity in the face of my terminal illness, this terrible brain cancer that has taken so much from me … but would have taken so much more. The world is a beautiful place, travel has been my greatest teacher, my close friends and folks are the greatest givers. I even have a ring of support around my bed as I type … Goodbye world. Spread good energy. Pay it forward!”
The right to die, and physician-assisted suicide, is nothing, if not controversial. Oregon’s own right-to-die law has experienced numerous attempts to block or repeal the law. Physicians have sharply criticized members of their trade doing anything that would not prolong life. And while Maynard was given a terminal prognosis, there are those rare cases when patients with similar medical conditions have somehow defied the odds and survived, which calls into question whether Maynard’s decision was as logical as she professed.
Maynard did not consider her own actions to be suicide. At length, in interviews in various media outlets, she said that she did not actually want to die, nor was she depressed. She merely accepted that because of her disease that she would die, she would die soon, and that she would suffer extensively before she did. And even then, hers was a decision, she said, she spent no small amount of time making.