How’d They Do? Judging Best 5 Investment Picks for 2012

A year ago, AdvisorOne published Best 5 Investment Picks for 2012 after analysts reported that corporate earnings were at an all-time high and the smart money was positioning investments for growth in 2012.

Data provided by top investment strategists at MFS Investments and ING Investment called for investors to put their money in:

1. Technology Sector
2. Mid-Cap Stocks
3. Dividend-Paying Stocks
4. High-Yield Credit
5. Emerging Markets

So how did the investment predictions do?

Like much of the market, they certainly got it right in the first half of 2012, suffered through a lousy June, then saw a mixed performance for the rest of the year. But overall, the MFS and ING experts didn’t do too badly. Check out the following results, where we compare the experts’ picks against the performance of a number of highly traded exchange traded funds (ETFs).

1. Technology Sector

The suggestion that Apple (AAPL) may be a good stock to hold in what MFS’ Jim Swanson calls the “defensive” tech sector was a good one in November 2011, and a year later Apple is up an impressive 53.13%.

However, the stock has taken a beating this quarter since disappointment over the new iPhone5 and tough competition in the tech space has taken the polish off Apple’s reputation as a never-fail corporation.

From Oct. 1 to Nov. 30, the stock has dropped 11.24%. Still, many companies would be happy to trade their numbers for Apple’s: as of early December, the current share price for Apple is around $550, and there has been market speculation that the stock could take off next year. State Street’s SPDR ETF Technology Select Sector (XLK), which includes Apple, outperformed the Dow Jones industrial average over the last year, yielding approximately 13.5% versus the Dow’s 8%.

2. Mid-Cap Stocks

Accelerating corporate profits, “booming” U.S. manufacturing and underestimated consumer strength both at home and abroad were the elements that ING Chief Market Strategist Douglas Coté cited as reasons to buy mid-cap stocks in 2012. “Investors need to position themselves for when the rallies come,” Coté said a year ago.

He was correct about mid-caps, which did better than the broader stock market. A year-over-year comparison of the SPDR S&P MidCap 400 (MDY) versus the Dow shows both reaching similar peaks and troughs throughout 2012, although MDY generally outperformed. The MidCap ETF as of Nov. 30 was yielding about 13% compared with about 8% for the Dow. S&P MidCap ETF has its largest share of holdings, 21.64%, in financials, with companies like Raymond James Financial.

3. Dividend-Paying Stocks

Swanson, chief investment strategist for MFS Investments, said last year that dividend payers like Duke Energy (DUK), were a “new defensive” sector. S&P 500 companies’ cash flows were experiencing a dramatically V-shaped profit recovery and clocking in at an all-time high, which promised dividends from quality stocks.