CBO's Estimates on Healthcare Bill Came With a Warning

As President Obama signed the sweeping healthcare legislation on March 23, he probably would have wanted the director of the Congressional Budget Office, Douglas W. Elmendorf, sitting nearby. The preliminary estimates of the reform bill’s costs released March 18 by the CBO helped bolster support for the bill three days before the House voted.

But those estimates came with a warning about the long-term viability of those projections.

The estimates by the nonpartisan agency landed right near the targets Obama had outlined for the bill’s costs. The CBO, which revised its estimates on March 20, said that over a 10-year period, ending in 2019, the new insurance provisions would reduce the deficit by $143 billion and cover 32 million people who lacked insurance. (The CBO said $19 billion of that savings stems from the education provisions that are attached to the health bill.) The CBO said the bill would not cover about 23 million people, a third of which were illegal immigrants.

The warning on these deficit-reduction numbers, comes not from dubious outsiders, but Elmendorf himself. He said in a blog posting in March that stretching the CBO’s projections through the 2020s would reduce the deficit around one-half percent of GDP. But the hedge on that prediction, he wrote, would assume that “the provisions of the legislation are enacted and remain unchanged throughout the next two decades, which is often not the case for major legislation.” Elmendorf added, “The current legislation would maintain and put into effect a number of policies that might be difficult to sustain over a long period of time.”

It’s just those budget-busting uncertainties about the bill that have some economic analysts sounding the alarm about the country’s financial future.