Close Close

Life Health > Annuities > Fixed Annuities

Throw away the spreadsheet

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

Here are two math problems to solve (and yes, you may use a calculator).

1. How would you compute the total interest paid on this loan? (You could also answer by providing the actual total interest paid.)

  • Home equity loan: 14.25% annual percentage rate
  • Ten year term, fixed rate
  • $10,000 financed
  • Monthly payment: $156.77

2. What are the miles per gallon for this final tank of gas?


  1. $8,812.40 ($156.77 payments x 120 months = $18,812.40 – $10,000 amount financed = $8,812.40 total interest)
  2. 25.0 (14650 end miles – 14350 start miles = 300 miles divided by 12.0 gallons = 25.0 mpg)

These questions were asked as part of a National Assessment of Adult Literacy exam and were testing basic (high school) level math skills in adults. Of the thousands of adults tested, only 40 percent of adults answered question No.1 correctly, only 29 percent could calculate mpg and only 22 percent knew how to compute the total interest.

Think about that. Even with the help of a calculator, 60 percent to 80 percent of adults could not answer these basic math questions. And yet the financial industry delights in creating spreadsheets and illustrations to show the consumer why the beta of 1.5 is creating a very attractive alpha intercept on that fund, or how a Himalayan option strategy may be better than a rainbow crediting method on the index annuity, without seeming to care that the math skills of 71 percent of retirees are rated basic or below.

There are two problems with this preoccupation with financial math. First, most prospects will not understand the financial math being presented; and second, this is not how most people buy things, especially if they are retirees looking at fixed annuities.

Our goals change as we realize death is nearing and we shift from seeking knowledge to deriving meaning from life and ensuring good feelings. Because of this, emotions become more important in processing information and retirees use more emotional cues rather than factual details. Retirees base their decisions on what is important to them. The retiree is not interested in knowing the numerical impact derived from having 60 percent of the return coming from the Podunk 75 Index and 40 percent from the Whoopdedoo 1000. Rather, he or she wants to know if the annuity offers peace of mind by providing money for the family and meets the goal of eliminating anguish every time the stock market heads south.

My friend Barb Cole says spreadsheets are good for research but bad for people; I believe the reason Barb is so successful is because she always does her research and then works with the whole person, and not just the cold numbers.


© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.