Close Close
Popular Financial Topics Discover relevant content from across the suite of ALM legal publications From the Industry More content from ThinkAdvisor and select sponsors Investment Advisor Issue Gallery Read digital editions of Investment Advisor Magazine Tax Facts Get clear, current, and reliable answers to pressing tax questions
Luminaries Awards

Retirement Planning > Saving for Retirement

Bankrate survey: Retirement savings at record levels

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

More Americans, especially younger people, are saving for retirement, and they’re socking away more money as well, according to a new Bankrate survey.

As much as 21 percent of people polled are saving more for retirement than last year, a new record-high percentage in Bankrate’s Financial Security Index. On the flipside, fewer people are choosing not to save anything for retirement. Just 5 percent didn’t contribute to retirement savings this year, a new low for the survey.

Related: Your 401(k) fees are attracting more attention — from lawyers

“Both readings are indicative of an improving economy, where people are earning more and saving more,” says Greg McBride, CFA, Bankrate’s chief financial analyst.

The specific question regarding retirement savings has been surveyed by Bankrate once a year for 5 of the past 6 years.

Lea Wenban is one of those who is saving more. The 45-year-old Palm Beach Gardens, Florida, resident admits she should have started saving when she was younger.

“I will save even more in the near future, and that is a mixture of being financially able to do so and being more savvy, more aware,” she says.

The results of Bankrate’s Financial Security Index for August mirror government economic benchmarks that show the U.S. continues to baby-step out of recession, and that has helped to increase retirement savings.

The FSI reached its second-highest level of the year at 104.5 (see chart below). A reading above 100 shows Americans have an improving sense of financial well-being.’

Related: Disaster-avoiding strategies for retirement beneficiaries

Americans’ financial security surges

Bankrate’s Financial Security Index has popped up to its second highest level in 2016.

Bankrate’s Financial Security Index is compiled using 5 monthly survey questions that track Americans’ feelings about their job security, savings, debt, net worth and overall financial situation. A reading above 100 indicates improvement in financial security, while a reading below 100 reflects weaker financial security.

“Household balance sheets are stronger due to lower debt burdens, record low household debt service ratios and a record high level of job openings (5.6 million),” says Steve Rick, a senior economist with the Credit Union National Association. “The last time the economy was this strong was back in 2007.”

Related: The Titanic risks of the retirement system

Companies help employees to save

The Bankrate survey results are also evidence of a changing retirement savings environment.

“The ongoing disappearance of traditional pension plans, and the precarious financial position of many of the remaining ones, puts the onus on individuals to save more,” says Alan MacEachin, corporate economist with Navy Federal Credit Union.

Adam Millsap, a research fellow with the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, says automatic enrollment in 401(k)s also has grown in popularity, boosting savings.

“Auto enrollment has been shown to increase the proportion of people who save,” Millsap says.

In addition, some employers are expanding their employer 401(k) match, according to Paychex, the payroll and benefits management company. That likely will induce people to save more for retirement, Millsap says.

Johnny Dilan, 35, of West Palm Beach, Florida, says he started saving at 29, deducting $150 per paycheck for retirement savings. As his pay increased after the recession, he boosted his contribution.

“This year, my 401(k) has a 6 percent match, and I max out my year contributions to my Roth IRA at tax time,” he says.

Younger generations are saving more

Perhaps most surprising in Bankrate’s survey was which age groups are leading the way in saving more now than last year for their retirement. Generation Xers (ages 36-51) led the pack at 26 percent, followed by younger millennials (ages 18-25) at 22 percent.

“Younger generations are likely saving more because they’re near the beginning of their life cycle and need to save more to reach their retirement objectives,” says Sam Rines, senior economist at Avalon Advisors LLC.

“The older generations have already done the majority of the saving they will do, and may see little point in putting additional dollars away at such low return levels,” he says.

Related: 17 unexpected expenses in retirement

Wages and jobs on the rise

The fact that younger generations have boosted savings may reflect an improving economy.

Indeed, the unemployment rate in the U.S. has fallen to 4.9 percent, as 547,000 new jobs were created in the past 2 months and workers got a 2.6 percent increase in wages over the past 12 months, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

That’s not to say that everyone is doing well. In Bankrate’s study, 17 percent of Americans are saving less than last year. But that statistic is consistent with FSI readings since 2012, when the range has held between 14 percent and 18 percent.

“Workers earning minimum wage — or near minimum wage — are likely unable to save for big-ticket items, or simply save in general,” Avalon Advisors’ Rines says. “The cost of living is simply too high.”

On that cost side, MacEachin, with Navy Federal Credit Union, says rising rent and health care expenses continue to erode discretionary income that otherwise could be used to boost savings.

Mercatus’ Millsap agrees, but he points to yet another cost that can take out a big chunk of family income and cut saving: a child’s college education.

Related: Annuities for retirement income

Younger baby boomers saving less for retirement

By age group, the so-called silent generation, those 71 and older, registered the largest percentage of Americans saving less than last year at 36 percent, followed by younger baby boomers (age 52-61) at 30 percent.

This is not a good sign, says Bankrate’s McBride.

Related: 17 unexpected expenses in retirement

“Younger baby boomers saving less for retirement than last year is troubling because they’re more likely in their peak earning years and should be using higher catch-up contribution limits to get on track for retirement,” he says. “Those in the silent generation who are saving less may be a function of earning less as they phase into retirement.”

Still, 56 percent of those surveyed are saving the same amount for retirement as last year, also a new high.

Americans feeling more secure about their jobs

Four of the 5 areas that make up Bankrate’s overall index — job security, debt, net worth and the respondent’s overall financial situation — showed improvement over last year.

Net worth and job security were high points of the August index. Americans reporting higher net worth than last year outnumbered those reporting lower net worth by more than 2-to-1 — nearly the same ratio of those feeling more secure in their jobs compared to those feeling less secure.

With unemployment falling from over 9 percent to 4.9 percent since 2011, the market’s run-up since 2009 and the recovery in home values, household finances have improved.

“Wage growth is also starting to improve finally, as the job market tightens. This has boosted many households’ confidence, wealth and incomes,” Navy Federal’s MacEachin says.


The retirement threat most people overlook

5 major risks to a client’s retirement income

The obvious retirement risk that’s not in the models

2 factors contributing to the growing problem of elder debt


© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.