Financial advisors and investors traditionally favor dividend-paying stocks as a key allocation in any comprehensive retirement portfolio, and Warren Buffett has famously earned billions owning such stocks. But Jim Cahn, chief investment officer of Wealth Enhancement Advisory Services in Minneapolis, says dividend-paying stocks are not nearly as safe or as remunerative as many think.
For one, says Cahn, dividend-paying stocks are more interest-rate sensitive than popularly thought and they will perform poorly as rates rise. He explains that investors owning these stocks as a substitute for bonds currently paying extremely low yields will likely lose value when rates rise, just like the bonds.
Also, says Cahn, “Some of the highest dividend-paying stocks tend to be some of the riskiest.” These include mortgage-backed real estate investment trusts, which are subject to even bigger losses as rates rise because they are often leveraged, says Cahn. They also include MLPs — master limited partnerships — which are subject to the volatility in the energy sector.
Dividend-paying stocks also tend to underperform, says Cahn. Since 2001, the Russell U.S. Large Cap High Dividend Index is up 99% on a total return basis while the Russell 1000 is up 130.8%, he says. Also, the Modigliani-Miller Theorem developed by Nobel prize-winning economists Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller “determined that payments of dividends has no impact on the value of a firm,” says Cahn.
What Your Peers Are Reading
Given this analysis, how should advisors and investors generate income?