Life Health > Life Insurance

NY Life To Refund Race-Based Payments

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.


New York Life Insurance Company has agreed to refund as much as $10 million to African-American policyholders who it acknowledges were charged higher premiums in the past because of their race.

Under an agreement with New York state regulators, New York Life will pay the refunds to African American owners of endowment policies sold during a period stretching from 1920 to 1948, or to surviving members of their families.

Endowment policies were term life contracts that paid back the premium, plus interest, to policyholders at the end of their terms, ranging from 10 to 20 years. New York Life no longer sells this type of policy.

The New York Insurance Department launched an investigation in June 2000 into charges of race-based underwriting among a number of carriers. MetLife Inc., New York, settled with the department shortly thereafter, promising to refund as much as $160 million for overcharges occurring for policies sold to African Americans in the past.

New York Lifes refunds will cover race-based overcharges, plus interest, according to the Insurance Department.

A spokesman for the company acknowledges that in the early 1900s, its underwriters considered race when evaluating mortality risk.

“Regrettably, in the social and legal environment of that period in the United States, this was standard industry practice,” the spokesman says. “At New York Life, those practices ended decades ago.”

Under the agreement, New York Life has launched a publicity campaign to notify customers who may have paid race-based premiums and to advise them or members of their families to contact the company.

The company says its will soon launch an ad campaign in Black Enterprise, Ebony, Jet, Family Digest and American Legacy magazines to help it identify former policyholders or their families who might have been affected by discriminatory premiums.

In addition, it set up a Web site,, to provide information on the settlement.

The deadline for submitting claims under the agreement is next April 30.

Investigations into other carriers race-based practices are continuing, the Insurance Department says.

Reproduced from National Underwriter Edition, July 2, 2004. Copyright 2004 by The National Underwriter Company in the serial publication. All rights reserved.Copyright in this article as an independent work may be held by the author.