SEC Tells ICI That Derivatives Disclosure Needs Improvement

Regulators argue that investors need more, better information

More On Legal & Compliance

from The Advisor's Professional Library
  • Updating Form ADV and Form U4 When it comes to disclosure on Form ADV, RIAs should assume information would be material to investors.  When in doubt, RIAs should disclose information rather than arguing later with securities regulators that it was not material.
  • Anti-Fraud Provisions of the Investment Advisers Act RIAs and IARs should view themselves as fiduciaries at all times, whether they meet the legal definition or not.  Deviating from the fiduciary standard of full disclosure while courting clients may cause the advisor significant problems.
In a July 30 letter to the Investment Company Institute (ICI), the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) urged funds that used derivatives to "assess the accuracy and completeness of their disclosure," and to use tailored disclosure statements that addressed how derivatives would be used in a particular fund, rather than depending on standardized disclosures.

"In determining the appropriate disclosure, a fund should consider the degree of economic exposure the derivatives create, in addition to the amount invested in the derivatives strategy," wrote Barry Miller, associate director in the SEC's Office of Legal and Disclosure. "This disclosure also should describe the purpose that the derivatives are intended to serve in the portfolio (e.g., hedging, speculation, or as a substitute for investing in conventional securities), and the extent to which derivatives are expected to be used."

Among the SEC's concerns about current disclosure statements is that information provided is too generic. Disclosures are "of limited usefulness" to investors, according to Miller's letter to the ICI, and fail to demonstrate how "the fund's investment adviser actually intends to manage the fund's portfolio and the consequent risks."

Furthermore, while some of these "generic disclosures" are limited in scope, others are too long or too technical, with details of potential derivative transactions and no indication of relevance to investment operations.

A typical derivative disclosure, Miller writes, states that the fund "will or may engage in derivative transactions," and lists all types of derivatives as possible investments. Disclosure statements may also be too generic about derivatives' purpose in the fund or the extent to which they will be used.

These same concerns extend to risk disclosures, which provide only a limited or generic explanation of risk, or overly-complex disclosures that "reduces its usefulness for investors."

"We are reviewing the SEC staff's letter on derivatives-related disclosures by investment companies," a spokesperson for ICI said. "We will work with our members to ensure that they understand and comply with their disclosure obligations."

Reprints Discuss this story
This is where the comments go.