Dire Straits for E Trade

Scathing report cites multiple problems for online broker and bank

Popular online broker, and bank, E Trade Financial Corporation (ETFC), may be the latest company to fall into the subprime and CDO vortex, facing trouble on November 12 as its stock traded in mid-afternoon at $3.58, down $5.01. That's more than 58% lower Friday's closing price of $8.59. The company filed a 10Q on Friday, November 9, and Citigroup analyst Prashant Bhatia downgraded ETFC in a Sunday, November 11, report. The analyst explained in the report that "the firm could face a potential run-on-the-bank scenario." Bhatia's report includes "a 15% probability of bankruptcy." Bhatia has changed his risk rating of ETFC to "Speculative Risk."

The Citigroup analyst's report, obtained by Investment Advisor, listed a target price for the stock of $7.50, down from $13.00, and E Trade's stock blew right through that $7.50 price target at the market's opening, with the stock price opening at $5.50. As of mid-afternoon, sellers outnumbered buyers 4.5 to 1. The Citigroup report goes on to note that "50% of E Trade deposits" an aggregate $15 billion, are over the FDIC insurance limit of $100,000, "and we view these deposits as having a higher risk of leaving. The $15 billion of deposits in 57,000 accounts represent roughly 25% of E*Trade's funding, and deposit attrition could lead to forced selling of the assets that are supported by these deposits."

Bhatia says in the report that the deposit concerns; additional write-downs in E Trade's subprime and CDO portfolio--including certain parts of the portfolio that were previously AAA-rated; and the announcement of "an SEC inquiry, and the filing of "three class-action lawsuits, and three verified shareholder derivative complaints," in October, are troubling. E Trade's home equity portfolio of more than $12 billion is problematic, as well, Bhatia explains in the report, with "over 60% of the home equity loan portfolio not having 'full documentation,'" and he estimates that the company will have to make higher loan-loss provisions of "$100 million per quarter going forward (versus $10 million to $13 million per quarter in 2006)."

Reprints Discuss this story
We welcome your thoughts. Please allow time for your contribution to be approved and posted. Thank you.

Most Recent Videos

Video Library ››