Let’s analyze the $16 billion market in U.S. listed ETNs to see the similarities.
ETNs vs. ETFs
While ETNs and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are sometimes grouped together, or worse, confused as the same thing, they are not.
Unlike traditional ETFs, exchange-traded notes are debt obligations backed by the financial or banking institution that issues them. ETNs pay a return linked to the performance of a single security or index. Who pays the return? The financial issuer backing the note.
ETNs can track a variety of assets from commodities (DJP), to the VIX Index (VXX) and Indian stocks (INP). ETNs are also used as day trading instruments for those that want leveraged long exposure (DGP) or leveraged short (DZZ) to gold or other assets.
Investors that choose to keep their ETN to maturity receive a cash payment calculated from the beginning trade date to the ending period, or maturity date. The annual fees deducted reduce the value of the payment.
Maturity periods can vary and may be as long as 30 years. ETN investors who don’t want to hold their note to maturity can sell it prior to maturity on the exchange where they trade.
Beyond the U.S.stock market’s (VTI) daily moves, Europe’s financial crisis has subtle domestic implications.
The U.S. ETN marketplace is heavily composed of products issued by European banks. Furthermore, it would be safe to say that European banks themselves don’t know how safe European banks are. Isn’t that why they’ve been hoarding cash, and isn’t that why they’ve been parking other vast amounts with the European Central Bank?
Here’s what ETFguide told its newsletter subscribers:
“From the very beginning of Europe’s crisis, its leading voices (from Europe’s Central Bank to its heads of state) have been consistent in one regard: They’ve continually underestimated the severity of the crisis each step of the way. They were wrong about Greece, Ireland and Portugal not needing bailouts – and they were badly wrong on the actual size of the bailout required. Is there any reason to believe they’ll be wrong (again) about the alleged soundness of Europe’s banking system?”
Which of Europe’s banks are illiquid, overleveraged or on the verge of bankruptcy? Is it Britain’s Barclays (BCS)? Is it Germany’s Deutsche Bank (DB)? Is it Switzerland’s UBS (UBS)? Or is it another institution? Soon enough, we’ll know.
Is History Repeating Itself?
Which ETNs are at the greatest risk of loss because of Europe’s financial crisis? The September ETF Profit Strategy Newsletter outlined who the top ETN providers are, which ones to avoid and a protection strategy for navigating the storm. During the ‘08-‘09 financial crisis, the ETNs issued by Lehman Brothers got clobbered and eventually became worthless.
Today, the $16 billion market for ETNs in the U.S. is much larger than it was three years ago, which means one thing: This time around, the same ETN blowup that’s on the verge of occurring will much larger in scale and much uglier.
In summary, financial advisors should be aggressive in protecting their clients from the credit risk of ETNs by sticking with traditional ETFs.