Oil Prices a Drag on Economy Despite Encouraging Signs: J.P. Morgan's Kelly

Kelly calls oil 'deflationary' in U.S. but not in developing markets

David Kelly, chief market strategist of J.P. Morgan Funds, hosted a call on Wednesday to address rising oil prices and political turmoil in the Middle East.

"Oil makes everyone very nervous," Kelly (left) began. Four of the major recessions since the 1970s have been preceded by spikes in oil prices, he said.

Oil is not inflationary in the United States, Kelly said, though it is in developing markets. In the United States, however, oil is deflationary because proceeds flow out of the country instead of to American producers.

There have been encouraging signs in the job market, Kelly told callers. For example, unemployment claims have declined, falling by 20,000 claims in the week ending Feb. 26, according to the Department of Labor. Additionally, the Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index rose 5.6 points to 70.4 in February and the percentage of consumers who predict fewer jobs will be available in the coming months fell from over 21% to 15.4%. And as if bad weather isn't bad enough, Kelly estimates more than 100,000 jobs weren't included in the January jobs report due to winter weather.

"If not for oil, you'd say the economy was moving up again," Kelly said.

The bottom line, he said, is to be overweight equities and underweight fixed income; and, of course, keep watching the price of oil.

Nishesh Kumar, energy analyst for J.P. Morgan Funds, noted that conditions in 2010 were very different from conditions in 2008.

If spare capacity falls below two million barrels a day, Kumar warned, it could lead to an increase in oil prices. However, "change in regime is not disruptive to supply," he said, noting that work started again in Tunisia two weeks ago and that physical disruptions have been limited to North African countries.

"If it spreads to Oman or Bahrain, the United States is where you start to see demand unroll first," he said.

Reprints Discuss this story
This is where the comments go.